Your course is always open, but is it selling?

You know that feeling when you’re about to miss something important?

Your heart beats a little faster. Your focus narrows. And suddenly, that thing you’ve been putting off becomes the only thing that matters.

It’s a tale as old as time.

Build a beautiful evergreen course, but then watch sales had flatline.

I mean, the course is “always available,” so who’s feeling compelled to buy now?

(Go ahead and reply… I’d love to know if you’ve experienced this too!)

So in this email, I’m going to show you:

• Why traditional urgency tactics kill your brand
• How to create “evolution urgency” that feels authentic
• The counterintuitive way to use tiered access

Let’s dive in…

Traditional urgency tactics are killing your brand

We’ve all seen it.

The countdown timer that mysteriously resets when you clear your cookies.

(Kinda like a magician who forgets to hide his rabbit.)

The “only 3 spots left!” claim on a digital product with unlimited capacity.

The “doors closing tonight!” email… followed by the “reopening for 24 hours only!” email three days later.

These tactics might boost short-term sales, but they’re eroding something far more valuable: trust.

A study by the Baymard Institute found that 69% of online shoppers abandon their purchase when they feel pressured or manipulated.

And in today’s hyper-connected world, your audience compares notes.

They know when you’re being authentic… and when you’re not.

So what’s the alternative?

How do you create genuine urgency for something that’s technically “always available”?

One answer lies in evolution, not expiration.

Most course creators treat their content as static, finished products.

But what if your course was positioned as a living, evolving asset?

For example, one tactic is to issue updates monthly with new case studies and tools. Students who enroll this month get lifetime access to all future updates, while later enrollees pay for updates separately.

This creates natural urgency without artificial deadlines.

It’s not about missing a discount—it’s about getting maximum value.

Remember: Urgency should come from opportunity, not manipulation.

The hidden cost of waiting (that your audience doesn’t see)

“I’ll just wait until I have more time.”

How often have your potential students told themselves this story?

The problem isn’t that they don’t want your course.

It’s that they don’t understand the true cost of delay.

Most course creators focus on what students gain by enrolling. But what about what they lose by waiting?

This is where quantifying procrastination becomes powerful.

What if you changed your approach from “here’s what you get” to “here’s what you miss every week you delay”?

• 3 live peer feedback sessions (archived, not interactive)
• 12 AI-powered growth audits (expire weekly)
• Access to monthly expert interviews (not recorded)

Suddenly, waiting doesn’t feel “free” anymore. There’s a tangible cost.

This approach works because it’s completely honest. You’re not creating fake scarcity—you’re highlighting real consequences that already exist.

And it appeals especially to driven entrepreneurs who hate inefficiency. They can’t stand the thought of leaving value on the table.

The next time you’re crafting your sales message, don’t just tell people what they’ll gain by joining. Show them what they’re losing by waiting.

Procrastination isn’t free—make sure your audience knows its price.

Tiered access: The counterintuitive urgency approach

Here’s where most course creators get it wrong.

They think urgency means closing doors completely. But what if, instead of closing doors, you opened new ones for early enrollees?

This is the “tiered access” approach, and it’s transforming how my clients sell their evergreen courses.

Here’s how it works:

Your base course remains available at its standard price ($997, for example). But this month only, students can add a private Slack community and monthly “hot seat” calls for $200 extra—an opportunity never offered again.

The core product stays evergreen, but the premium experience becomes scarce.

This creates urgency without compromising your evergreen model. It’s not about manipulating people into buying—it’s about rewarding those who commit early with additional value.

The psychology is fascinating. When people know they can always get the base product, they feel less pressure. But the limited premium option creates just enough FOMO to prompt action.

Think about it like concert tickets.

Metallica is going to play whether you buy floor seats or balcony—but the premium experience is limited.

Your evergreen course isn’t just a product—it’s a membership with tiers of access.

The long game wins

The unimaginative use urgency as a “hack.” But by tying it to ongoing value delivery instead of arbitrary deadlines, you:

1. Preserve trust (no manipulative tactics)
2. Increase perceived value (your course evolves with the market)
3. Attract serious buyers (urgency stems from ROI, not fear)

This approach transforms your evergreen courses from static products into high-status memberships—aligning perfectly with building both profit and brand authority.

So next time you’re tempted to add another countdown timer, ask yourself: “Is this urgency authentic to my brand?”

Because in the long run, trust outperforms tricks.

‍